Capital Berg

Keeps People Up-To-Date

Tuesday, April 13, 2021
Log in
  • United States
  • Business
  • Health
  • Science
  • Technology
  • About CapitalBerg
    • Analysts & Contributors
    • Advertising
    • Contact US
    • Privacy Policy GDPR
    • Terms of Use

Pages

  • About CapitalBerg
  • Advertising
  • Analysts & Contributors
  • Contact US
  • Investor Relations
  • Privacy Policy GDPR
  • SEC Disclosure
  • Terms of Use

Recent Posts

  • Tennessee Rapist Breaks into Woman’s House Three Times the Same Night to Assault Her June 29, 2018
  • Mentally Ill Man Arrested After Breaking into Retirement Home to Grope a Woman’s Chest June 28, 2018
  • “Syndrome” Author Blake Leibel Sentenced to Life in Prison for the Murder and Torture of Girlfriend June 27, 2018
  • Michigan Dad to Be Sentenced in the Beating Death of 3-Year-Old Infant June 26, 2018
  • Ohio Patrolman Booted from Police After Pulling Over His Daughter and Boyfriend June 26, 2018
  • Utah Mayor Shares Heartwarming Letter of Man Apologizing for Stealing a Stop Sign 75 Years Ago June 25, 2018
  • Mississippi Man Beheaded Mother After A Spat over Credit Cards June 25, 2018

PLOS ONE Paper Cited a ‘Creator’, Outraging Scientists

March 5, 2016 By Andreas Petersen

"creatorgate"

Religion has always been one of the most heated topics of discussion. Both creationists and evolutionists have their own arguments for why they’re right, and few things can be said to convince either side that the other one is right. And since they pretty much disprove one another, tensions tend to run quite high.

In one of the most recent scandals on the matter, dubbed by some #Creatorgate and by others #HandofGod, PLOS ONE paper cited a ‘Creator’, outraging scientists. While the journal apologized and retracted the article and everything was attributed to being lost in translation, the scientific world is still outraged at a science journal citing the existence of God.

The “scandalous” paper

Usually viewed as a decent scientific journal, PLOS ONE will most likely not be able to make it out of this debacle unscahthed, or at least minus a few dozen readers. It all started with a paper published in the journal, focused on analyzing the movement of the human hand.

The hand movements of thirty subjects were analyzed extensively in the paper called “Biomechanical Characteristic Of Hand Coordination In Grasping Activities Of Daily Living”, and the researchers attributed the complex design to a ‘Creator’. This ‘Creator’ is mentioned several times throughout the paper, sparking a huge scandal.

Lashing out

The scientific community immediately lashed out on Twitter and other social media platforms, denouncing the journal for being a joke, for reaching a new low, and claiming that they won’t be able to take anything written in it seriously again.

Several influential men and women of science talked about how it is an outrage to off-handedly mention a ‘Creator’ in a scientific paper and rightfully criticized the journal’s editors who did indeed let several mentions of a higher power slip into a scientific publication.

Apologies and retraction

Pretty much every party involved in the debacle apologized for causing the public outrage. The journal’s staff apologized for letting the article slip, and admitted that it was not even addressed during the paper’s review and evaluation. The also announced that they will be retracting the article in light of the scandal it caused and use of unscientific terminology.

Meanwhile, the team behind the paper also apologized, insisting that everything was just a translation error. Indeed, the entire team is Chinese, including the editor, and something really may have been lost in translation. According to them, they referred to an intelligent design and to the force of evolution when they said ‘Creator’.

It does make sense in the context, and in my opinion, everything was a gross exaggeration. Aside from the scandalous translation issue, the paper was perfectly well done. The methodology, experiments, premise and conclusion were all right. The best thing for all involved parties would be to retract the article, make the appropriate changes, and republish it, as the team did do a very good job with it.

Image source: Pixabay

  • About the Author

About Andreas Petersen

Andreas was too little to remember when he and his parents first set foot in America. He considers himself a true American citizen, but uses every opportunity to promote his Danish origins. He is deeply found of politics, all nations’ politics and generally looks forward to the presidential elections. His BA degree in Political Sciences has helped him get familiar to the constitutional frames of US and non-US nations.

Filed Under: Science

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 44 other subscribers

Recent Articles

sleep

Tennessee Rapist Breaks into Woman’s House Three Times the Same Night to Assault Her

June 29, 2018 By Denise Ehrlich Leave a Comment

police lights

Mentally Ill Man Arrested After Breaking into Retirement Home to Grope a Woman’s Chest

June 28, 2018 By Waleed Javed Leave a Comment

gavel

“Syndrome” Author Blake Leibel Sentenced to Life in Prison for the Murder and Torture of Girlfriend

June 27, 2018 By Andreas Petersen Leave a Comment

Woods

Michigan Dad to Be Sentenced in the Beating Death of 3-Year-Old Infant

June 26, 2018 By Marlene R. Litten Leave a Comment

patrol cruiser

Ohio Patrolman Booted from Police After Pulling Over His Daughter and Boyfriend

June 26, 2018 By Waleed Javed Leave a Comment

stop sign

Utah Mayor Shares Heartwarming Letter of Man Apologizing for Stealing a Stop Sign 75 Years Ago

June 25, 2018 By June Harris Leave a Comment

Butter knives

Mississippi Man Beheaded Mother After A Spat over Credit Cards

June 25, 2018 By Carol Harper Leave a Comment

XXXTentacion mugshot

Florida Authorities Arrested Suspect in Connection with Shooting of XXXTentacion

June 22, 2018 By Waleed Javed Leave a Comment

sunset over beach

Dallas Mother Accused of Beating Four-Year-Old and Dumping Body Into the Water

June 21, 2018 By Denise Ehrlich Leave a Comment

chicken Alfredo

Ohio Man Sentenced for Trying to Seduce Teenage Boy with Naked Pictures and Chicken Alfredo

June 20, 2018 By Marlene R. Litten Leave a Comment

bedroom

South Carolina Teen and Mates End Up In Slammer for Raping a Teenage Girl

June 19, 2018 By Waleed Javed Leave a Comment

cyberstalkin

California Man Arrested for Stalking Ex-Girlfriend, Hacking Her Online Accounts

June 19, 2018 By June Harris Leave a Comment

hammer

Naked Patient Sneaks out of Emergency Room to Bash Homeowner’s Head with Hammer

June 18, 2018 By Carol Harper Leave a Comment

screwdriver

Middle School Student Attacks Teacher During Class with Screwdriver

June 18, 2018 By Andreas Petersen Leave a Comment

Related Articles

  • Stephen Hawking watching a screen while sitting in his chair

    Stephen Hawking’s Family Sends His Final Message to Space

    Jun 15, 2018
  • super earth exoplanet half in shadow

    Is Gravity the Force Keeping Aliens from Visiting Earth? European Scientists Say So (Study)

    May 8, 2018
  • starbust stars and galaxies in the universe

    Thousands of Early Galaxies Revealed by Map of Old Universe (Study)

    Apr 10, 2018
  • statue of a neanderthal half shadowed

    Scientists Found a Possible Explanation for the Neanderthals’ Big Noses (Study)

    Apr 10, 2018
  • the planet venus

    Could the Clouds of Venus Be Holding Forms of Life?

    Apr 5, 2018
  • NASA and Parker Solar Probe Study

    NASA Ready to Send the Parker Solar Probe on its First Mission

    Mar 7, 2018
  • stars and galaxies in the universe

    Scientists Measure the Expansion Rate of the Universe, Challenge Physics?

    Feb 26, 2018
  • sunspots on the sun in close up

    Is the Sun Going to Get Dimmer and Cooler in the Next Decades? (Study)

    Feb 12, 2018
  • Two mummified brothers

    Egyptian Tale of Two Mummified Brothers Takes Unexpected Turn

    Jan 18, 2018
  • Futuristic robot holding its arms spread

    A New Type of Revolutionary Robotic Muscles Is Strong, Flexible, and Cheap (Study)

    Jan 7, 2018

Categories

  • Business
  • Deals
  • Health
  • Science
  • Technology
  • United States
  • World

Copyright © 2021 capitalberg.com

About · Privacy Policy · Terms of Use · Contact